COMPARISON
CHART
|
| LAW |
SECTION
4(f) |
SECTION
106 |
SECTION
6(f) |
|
Legislative
Reference
|
Section
4(f) of DOT Act |
National
Historic Preservation Act, Section 106
|
Land
and Water Conservation Fund Act, Section 6(f) |
|
Type
of Legislation
|
Preservation |
Preservation |
Preservation |
|
Purpose
|
Avoid
use of public parks, waterfowl and wildlife refuges and
significant historic sites |
Protect,
rehabilitate, restore and re-use districts, sites, buildings, structures
and objects significant in American architecture, archeology and culture |
Preserve, develop
and assure the quality and quantity of outdoor parks and recreation areas
and refuges for present and future generations |
|
Applies to ...
|
US
Department of Transportation projects |
Federal
projects |
Federal
projects |
|
Affects
...
|
Significant
public parks, recreation areas, wildlife and waterfowl refuges, and all
significant historic sites "used" for a highway project |
All
properties on or eligible for inclusion on the National Register of Historic
Places |
All
projects that impact recreational lands purchased or improved with land
and water conservation funds |
|
General
Procedures
|
Must
avoid protected areas, if feasible and prudent; must include all possible
planning to minimize harm |
Must
identify and determine the effects of project on subject properties; must
give Advisory Council an early opportunity to comment; must avoid or mitigate
effects as much as possible |
Secretary
of Interior must approve any conversion of property acquired or developed
with assistance under this act |
|
Requirements
|
Consultation,
avoidance or mitigation |
Consultation
and mitigation when affected |
Consultation,
avoidance or mitigation |
|
Coordination
with ...
|
DOI,
DOA, HUD, State Preservation Officer, State or local agencies with jurisdiction |
State
Historic Preservation Officer, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation,
DOI (National Park Service) |
DOI,
state agencies |
|
Relationship
to other statutes
|
Sections
6(f) and 106 are integral to Section 4(f) compliance |
Sections
4(f) and 6(f) are not integral to Section 106 process |
Sections
4(f) and 106 are not integral to Section 6(f) process |
| Relationship
to NEPA |
Considered
in the NEPA process |
Considered
in the NEPA process |
Considered
in the NEPA process |
 |